Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Why doesn't India seperate into two countries?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Why doesn't India seperate into two countries?

    If the Indian Nations do not unite why doesn't India seperate into two more nations . Let's think about it, South India has never been apart of India until the British came. Heck Tamil-Nadu, Kerella, and a few more states of the South have different cultures altogether.

    Why not? The muslims got to have there own country so why not give the South there own country? It would make sense!
    Last edited by Silverbackman; 09-24-2005, 07:38 AM.

  • #2
    Did Alexander the Great conquer India? No, not if you consider the Southern States as India. Did the Huns really conquer India? Now not if you consider Souther States India. Did the Mughal Persians conquer India? No, not if you consider the South to be apart of this India.

    Clearly makes little sense to me! Why do muslims get there own people and not Tamil people?

    Comment


    • #3
      regarding topic

      Why should anyone want to commit follies of the past again and balkanise India?
      What has happened has happened and it can't be reversed without causing as much bloodshed and hatred as was caused to make it happen. Why not think about developing the country that is there instead of thinking of causing instability?

      Comment


      • #4
        Originally posted by observer
        Why should anyone want to commit follies of the past again and balkanise India?
        What has happened has happened and it can't be reversed without causing as much bloodshed and hatred as was caused to make it happen. Why not think about developing the country that is there instead of thinking of causing instability?
        Irony .

        Anyway I think it is unfair that Muslims get their own country but not Tamils. If we use the logic of why the Indian Nations were seperate then why not come to that conclusion.

        Observer, I'm curious in your opinion on the Palestine-Israel conflict. What do you think about it and who do you think is the bad side between the 2 nations?

        Comment


        • #5
          My first question is; is the user Silverbackman a Jew or Jewish? Next, I don't like the idea of people encouraging India to split into nation-states. That's just stupid. India has always been a nation in one form or the other over a period of longtime. Indian culture is a 'gestalt' of it's state cultures and tradition. And without doubt Indian tradition and culture are founded on Hinduism and it will remain so. All the Leftists can leave India if they want a godless commie state. The marxists have always waged a 'cold war' using propaganda to keep India divided(even during the British era).
          Last edited by megrisoft; 12-06-2005, 09:37 AM.

          Comment


          • #6
            Originally posted by Silverbackman
            If the Indian Nations do not unite why doesn't India seperate into two more nations . Let's think about it, South India has never been apart of India until the British came. Heck Tamil-Nadu, Kerella, and a few more states of the South have different cultures altogether.

            Why not? The muslims got to have there own country so why not give the South there own country? It would make sense!
            You are acting so stupid now. Muslims wanted a separate nation cause they wanted it for greed. They wanted it. Tamils want to be a part of India. They don't want to be separate. we didn't let Pakistan be Pakistan. They forcefully became. There were many muslims who wanted to be in India and there are more Muslims in India then in Pakistan. Please stop this childish discussion.

            Try to go to next stage. Instead of planning to divide India talk about how to improve India as a whole.

            Comment


            • #7
              Originally posted by India1989
              You are acting so stupid now. Muslims wanted a separate nation cause they wanted it for greed. They wanted it. Tamils want to be a part of India. They don't want to be separate. we didn't let Pakistan be Pakistan. They forcefully became. There were many muslims who wanted to be in India and there are more Muslims in India then in Pakistan. Please stop this childish discussion.

              Try to go to next stage. Instead of planning to divide India talk about how to improve India as a whole.

              There was a point to this thread. It is to show the irony! Hopefully you see that .

              Comment


              • #8
                What's the irony?

                Comment

                Working...
                X